Friday, April 23, 2021

Relational Misconceptions Part 1: Relationships and Tables

Amid the plethora of industry misconceptions, an article titled "What if I told you there are no tables in relational databases?" is surprising. That it starts with:

“I’ve seen one sentence about relational databases repeated on the Web many, many times. I’ve seen it in countless comments, I’ve seen it in few articles. Recently I’ve even seen it in one book — which finally made me write this article. The sentence in question goes like this: "Ironically, relational databases deal poorly with relationships". Read it carefully. Think about it for a moment. I’m sure it must sound perfectly reasonable — for anyone who doesn’t understand the meaning of both "relational" and "irony".”

is practically shocking. Be that as it may, my regular readers know that I refer to pronouncements on the RDM as "heart in the right place": correct statements are not a guarantee of full grasp thereof, or effective explanations to practitioners lacking the necessary foundation knowledge. Hence this two part debunking.

Sunday, April 11, 2021

TYFK: Relations, Tables, and Semantic Consistency

Note: Each "Test Your Foundation Knowledge" post presents one or more misconceptions about data fundamentals. To test your knowledge, first try to detect them, then proceed to read our debunking, reflecting the current understanding of the RDM, distinct from whatever has passed for it in the industry to date. If there isn't a match, you can review references -- reflecting the current understanding of the RDM, distinct from whatever has passed for it in the industry to date -- which explain and correct the misconceptions. You can acquire further knowledge by checking out our POSTS, BOOKS, PAPERS, LINKS (or, better, organize one of our on-site SEMINARS, which can be customized to specific needs).

“A relation, or table, in a relational database ... must have a set of columns or attributes, and it must have a set of rows to contain the data. A tuple (or row) can be a duplicate. In practice, a database might actually contain duplicate rows, but there should be practices in place to avoid this, such as the use of unique primary keys (next up). Given that a tuple cannot be a duplicate, it follows that a relation must contain at least one attribute (or column) that identifies each tuple (or row) uniquely. This is usually the primary key. This primary key cannot be duplicated.”



  • A relation is not a table and, thus, has neither columns, nor rows (certainly not fields);
  • "Duplicate tuples" is a contradiction in terms -- a table with duplicate rows does not visualize a relation (i.e., is not a R-table) -- and a database with duplicated data is not relational;
  • Unlike a mathematical relation, there is no such thing as a database relation without a PK, which would be semantically inconsistent (i.e. it would not be a faithful representation of group of entities, which are distinguishable in the real world);



  • A database relation:
- is a relationship among domains (sets of values) -- a subset of their cross-product -- a set of tuples (sets of values drawn from the domains) or, in other words, a set of sets from sets;
- has attributes, which are representations (1:1 mappings) of the domains in the relation;
- is semantically constrained to be consistent with (i.e., represent faithfully) the entity group in the conceptual model represented by the database), including by a PK constraint:
. domains represent properties;
. relations represent entity groups;
. attributes represent entity properties;
. tuples represent (facts about -- properties of) entities;
. some constraints represent relationships among properties, entities and groups (some properties are relationships);
  • Duplication would violate the RDM and mean semantic inconsistency with (inaccurate representation of) the group.
  • A R-table visualizes a relation on some physical medium -- it plays no part in the relational model.

Further Reading

What Relations Really Are and Why They Are Important

Understanding Relations series

What Is a Relational Database

View My Stats